‍

In today’s competitive landscape, benchmarking can be transformative, helping successful SMEs (small and medium-sized enterprises) stand out from those that struggle. Benchmarking—comparing organisational performance and processes—provides management with insights into the best strategic approaches for their business (ASQ, 2019; Fallon, 2023). For SMEs, benchmarking identifies areas for improvement, helps adopt best practices from industry leaders, and boosts competitiveness. This report offers practical insights that would otherwise demand a costly and time-intensive internal analysis.

SMEs play a critical role in the economy. Outnumbering larger companies, they account for two-thirds of all private-sector jobs in the EU, making them vital to economic stability and growth (Demetriades & Eiffe, 2024). However, maintaining competitiveness presents several challenges, such as scaling difficulties, regulatory burdens, and innovation barriers—often due to limited resources compared with larger firms (Roper, Belt & Hart, 2024). These challenges are compounded by restricted access to capital and a lack of economies of scale. SMEs must work strategically to capture market share and differentiate themselves despite these barriers.

‍

Measuring Competitive Success:

SMEs can adopt several approaches to benchmarking, including financial, operational, market positioning, and customer satisfaction metrics. Each approach serves as a critical measure of competitive success, supporting data-driven decision-making and operational refinement.

Financial KPIs are essential for assessing profitability and financial health:

• Revenue Growth Rate: Measures total revenue over a specific period (Shad, 2023).
• Gross and Net Profit Margins: Gross margin assesses production efficiency, while net margin evaluates overall profitability (Shopify, 2022).
• Return on Assets (ROA): Indicates how effectively a company generates profit from its assets (Boyte-White, 2022).
• Inventory Turnover: Shows how often stock is sold and replaced, assessing whether inventory aligns with sales (Jenkins, 2022).

Operational KPIs differ from financial metrics by focusing on the efficiency of daily operations. For instance, revenue per employee measures how effectively employees contribute to revenue generation, spotlighting productivity. Other key operational metrics include the customer retention rate and acquisition cost, both vital for sustainable growth (Customer Thermometer, n.d.).

Customer Satisfaction also gauges success, often through surveys or metrics like the Net Promoter Score (NPS) and customer churn rate (Qualtrics, 2024). Market Positioning, too, is crucial; SMEs should understand their market share by comparing total company revenue against industry-wide totals (Nickolas, 2019). In addition, tracking online engagement through metrics like click-through rates (CTR) for websites or advertisements can reveal customer interest (WordStream, 2020).

Given that benchmarks differ across industries—retail relies on location and demographics, while tech SMEs focus on innovation and manufacturing prioritises quality control—it’s crucial that SMEs select KPIs aligned with both industry standards and long-term objectives.

‍

A 5-Step Guide to Benchmarking

We recommend a structured five-step approach to benchmarking:

1. Define Objectives
SMEs should identify the specific areas they aim to improve, aligning these objectives with broader company goals. Objectives may include enhancing operational efficiency, customer satisfaction, or financial performance.

‍

2. Select Specific KPIs
With objectives in place, SMEs should choose relevant KPIs to measure progress. These KPIs will provide actionable insights that guide decision-making. Any of the KPIs mentioned above could serve this purpose.

‍

3. Identify Competitors
Competitors can be categorised into three groups:

• Direct Competitors: Those with similar products/services and target markets.
• Indirect Competitors: Those within the same industry but offering different products or targeting different customers.
• Substitute Competitors: Firms targeting the same customer base but with distinct product offerings

.

4. Identify Data Sources and Gather Competitor Information
Based on the objective, SMEs should determine the best data sources to collect competitor information. For instance, to improve financial performance, SMEs could analyse competitor pricing and market positioning. If the focus is customer satisfaction, examining product quality, features, and brand reputation might be more insightful. Recommended tools include:

• SimilarWeb: Website traffic analysis and engagement metrics.
• SEMrush: SEO and PPC insights, keyword research, and backlink monitoring.
• Ahrefs: Backlink analysis and keyword difficulty evaluation.
• BuzzSumo: Social media analytics for trend and influencer insights.
• Competitors App: Product listings, price monitoring, and promotion tracking.

‍

5. Conduct Analysis and Compare Performance
SMEs should explore these five analytical areas:

1. Competitive Usability: Evaluate competitors’ website design, user experience, and A/B testing (tools like Versionista can assist).
2. Value Proposition Comparison: Assess competitors' unique selling points and alignment with market standards.
3. Customer Feedback: Analyse testimonials and reviews, potentially surveying competitor customers for deeper insights.
4. Quantitative Analysis: Examine patterns and strengths in metrics such as pricing, satisfaction, and operational efficiency.
5. SWOT Analysis: Identify the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats of competitors, ideally conducting a SWOT analysis of their own company as well.

‍

‍

Challenges and Limitations

Despite the numerous benchmarking tools available, SMEs may encounter limitations, particularly in niche or specialised markets where comparative data is scarce. Access to high-quality data is essential to prevent misguided decisions. Additionally, relying solely on benchmarking without considering other factors can lead to ineffective changes (Lister-Barker, 2024). To address these issues, SMEs might:

• Join industry associations to access shared data.
• Use open-source or low-cost software for data collection.
• Prioritise KPIs that align closely with the business’s strategic goals.
• Assess data reliability to ensure informed conclusions.

‍

Benchmarking is a vital tool for SMEs, allowing them to pinpoint inefficiencies and drive growth. This report highlights the challenges SMEs face, especially with limited resources, yet shows how effective benchmarking across financial, operational, customer satisfaction, and market positioning areas can support sustainable success. With careful KPI selection and the right tools, SMEs can gain substantial competitive advantages, as demonstrated in the accompanying case study, which shows a marked improvement in market share through benchmarking practices.

‍